Monday, November 17, 2014

Mascara Monday: Roundup!

Over the summer, I came to the realization that I had a ridiculous amount of mascara samples. (Thanks in large part to Ipsy and Birchbox subscriptions!) I wanted to do a "Mascara Monday" project to share how they all look applied to my lashes. I photographed all the different mascaras I had either samples or full sizes of and took notes on their application and formula. I posted one mascara with a mini review each Monday for a couple months on Instagram, but I also want to have a place where you can see them all together. This is a roundup of all the mascaras I tried (in alphabetical order) with mini reviews, including a few that never made it to Instagram.

High End Brand Mascaras:
**In each photo grid, the left photo has no makeup and the right only has mascara applied. There are two coats of mascara on my top lashes and one coat on the bottom in all the mascara photos. Click photo to enlarge.**
Bare Minerals Flawless Definition: Great separation and lengthening with little to no clumps. I liked the shape of the brush, with the sort of hourglass shape. It made for easy application to both top and bottom lashes. This was one of the more difficult ones to remove out of this set of mascaras but I did like the overall effect.
Bare Minerals Lash Domination: This has a really interesting brush, plastic and sort of swirled. I wasn't a fan of the brush, I thought it made application more difficult and really messy. I also felt this one made my lashes stick together more than I'd like.

Benefit Bad Gal Lash: Lengthening, separation and volume were all fine with this. The oversized brush is almost too big in my opinion, but it does have a tapered tip which helps. Overall, I thought it was decent but not amazing. The super sized brushes just aren't my thing.
Benefit They're Real: I do like this mascara, just not as much as most people. The plastic brush is great for easy application with length and separation, I just think the formula is a little too wet. While not my absolute favorite of the bunch, this is definitely one of the better mascaras I tried.

Buxom Amplified Lash: This is one of my all time favorite mascaras. I feel like it is really underrated and no one ever talks about it. The tip of the wand twists to lengthen or shorten the plastic brush. It separates well and there are virtually no clumps after application. The length and volume I achieve with this mascara makes me feel like I'm wearing false lashes without all the hassle.
Buxom Sculpted Lash: I was really unsure of the long, S-shaped brush with plastic bristles. It turned out to not be as bad at applying mascara as I thought, but it is still kinda weird to use. The formula is nice, as with every Buxom mascara I have tried, but not nearly as lengthening as the Amplified Lash.

Chanel Inimitable Intense: The brush is on the smaller side with plastic bristles and a tapered tip. This made for very nice and very easy application. The volume is great, as is the separation. There were a few really tiny clumps, I'm guessing this has to do with how dry the formula is. I remember the word "feathery" came to mind when I looked at my lashes after applying it. I think it gives a natural but enhanced look. I liked this mascara overall, though I'm not sure I would buy the full size.
Dior Diorshow New Look: This had the smallest brush of all the mascaras I tried. It had plastic bristles and a tapered tip. I like the smaller brushes for application, I feel like you are really able to get to the base of your lashes and get all the small tiny lashes in the corner as well. The separation wasn't stellar with this one, but the length was good.

Georgio Armani Eyes to Kill: The brush is on the larger side, but I actually really like the way it applied mascara. I found it applied really easily and without clumping. I really like the length and separation I got with this mascara. I felt the overall effect was a really nicely enhanced natural look. This was one of my favorites of the bunch. I had a sample but would definitely buy a full size.
Lancome Hypnose Star: The flat, triangular shaped brush on this mascara was quite different than your average mascara brush and I didn't care for it much. The formula seemed to make my lashes stick to each other a fair amount, though length was good. Unfortunately, I wasn't a fan overall.

Laura Mercier Full Blown Volume: The medium sized, long and slim brush made for easy application. I liked the length and lack of clumps but felt the separation could have been better. This was a nice mascara, not at the top of my list of favorites but not at the bottom either.
MAC Zoom Lash: The brush is medium sized and slightly tapered, it was easy to apply mascara with. As far as formula, there is some slight clumping and I would have preferred a little more separation. As with the Laura Mercier, it's a fine mascara but not the best of what I have tested.

Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant: I was surprised by how easy it actually was to use the large tear drop shaped brush. It applied easily to my lashes, adds great length, allows good separation between lashes and there were no clumps. This is a really nice mascara.
Marc Jacobs Lash Lifter Gel Volume: What stood out most about this mascara was how wet the formula is! The length was decent but my lashes stuck together quite a bit. I also noticed some little clumps near the tips of some lashes. I couldn't get over the wetness, this was just okay to me.

Smashbox Full Exposure: This has a jumbo brush with a tapered tip, much like Benefit's Bad Gal. The brush applied similarly to Bad Gal: it's a little difficult to work with because it's almost too big but it gets the job done. I thought the formula on this was a bit better than Bad Gal though, very nice separation and length. While large brushes usually aren't my favorite, in this case it worked out well and I really like the effect of this mascara.
Too Faced Better Than Sex: I like the shape of this brush, the sort of hourglass curve works really well for application. I thought this added great volume and length with almost no clumping. I really liked this mascara overall and would definitely consider purchasing a full size.

Drugstore Brand Mascaras:
**In each photo grid, the left photo has no makeup and the right only has mascara applied. There are two coats of mascara on my top lashes and one coat on the bottom in all the mascara photos. I went a little out of alphabetical order here so I could compare the two L'Oreal mascaras side by side. Click photo to enlarge.**
Essence Get BIG! Lashes Triple Black: This has a jumbo brush, which as I already mentioned I am not typically a fan of. However, it also has a slight hourglass shape to it, which really helped me out. I actually though it applied pretty easily. It added good volume and length, had good separation and no clumps. I thought it was a solid drugstore mascara.
Wet n Wild Mega Protein: The brush on this is a pretty standard old school mascara brush. The bristles were pretty far apart which made my eyelashes stick together in little groups. It didn't add much in terms of length or volume, it basically just darkened my lashes and made them stick together. If Wet n Wild makes a good mascara, this definitely isn't it.

L'Oreal Lash Out Voluminous Butterfly: The brush of this mascara is shaped kinda like, you guessed it, a butterfly's wings. To me, this shape is a really bizarre concept and didn't really work as expected. It just seems kinda gimmicky to me. The formula was kinda wet, not my favorite. Length was good and there weren't really any clumps. Maybe there is a learning curve to making this brush to amazing things to your eyelashes, but I didn't really care to keep using it long enough to find out.
L'Oreal Voluminous Million Lashes: This is my current favorite drugstore mascara. The plastic brush is big but not jumbo and has a nice tapered tip making application really easy. I find I get great volume, length and separation without clumps. I think it rivals some of the top prestige brands like Benefit or Buxom. I will definitely continue to purchase this as a drugstore mascara option.

Favorite High End: Buxom Amplified Lash, Georgio Armani Eyes to Kill
Favorite Drugstore: L'Oreal Voluminous Million Lashes
Least Favorite: Wet n Wild Mega Protein

Many of the mascara samples I tried out came from my subscriptions to Birchbox and Ipsy. If you are interested in joining either, please consider using my referral link! (I get points if you join through my link.) 
Ipsy Referral Link & Birchbox Referral Link. Thank You! :)


For more Cosmetic Addiciton, make sure to follow me on Instagram @CosmeticAddictionTwitter @CosmeticAddictn and Facebook!

No comments:

Post a Comment

I welcome your feedback! If you have any questions, comments or suggestions please feel free to share them with me. Thank you! :)